Content warning: stalking, harassment, threats, violence–GamerGate, basically.
Geek Feminism’s lack of a statement about the GamerGate hate campaign has felt conspicuous to me. We’re a community dedicated to promoting justice and equality within geek communities. Documenting harassment and abuse in geek communities is one of our biggest projects. GamerGate is on our beat.
But while our fabulous team of linkspammers has been on top of the story, we haven’t put up a statement.
I spoke to some of our other bloggers about ways we could respond. The conversation we had was pretty illustrative.
Here are the ideas we had, and why we discarded them:
1: A “Seriously, Fuck GamerGate” Post
Why we didn’t:
“Fuck GamerGate” is a fairly obvious statement from us. It might be satisfying to say, but it adds little to the conversation.
And women who’ve said it before us have been stalked, harassed, doxxed, and threatened–some to the point of fleeing their homes.
2. A statement of support for GamerGate’s victims
Why we didn’t:
Telling folks we support them is nice, but it doesn’t provide the victims of these terror campaigns with the practical support they need to protect themselves. Talking about them has a very high chance of exposing them to even more abusers. When you’re the target of an organized campaign of terror, the last thing you need is more attention.
And women who’ve made statements of support have been stalked, harassed, doxxed, and threatened–some to the point of fleeing their homes.
3. An Ada Lovelace-style celebration of women in gaming, where we encourage folks to blog about games they love by women, and women in gaming who inspire them.
Why we didn’t:
We didn’t want to paint a target on anyone’s back.
Women in gaming who’ve gotten positive attention have been stalked, harassed, doxxed, and threatened–some to the point of fleeing their homes.
4. Present an iron hide and dare them to bring it.
Some of us feel guilty for not telling GamerGaters exactly where they can shove the horseshit they have the temerity to present as discourse.
Why we didn’t:
We want to live in a world where terror campaigns like this are ineffective; where that which does not kill us makes us stronger; where good triumphs over obtuse, selfish, cowardly evil. But wanting to live in that world doesn’t make that world real. In this world, oppression and injustice have built a system whereby that which does not kill us often leaves us personally and professionally damaged.
The fantasy that bravado would win the day is appealing, but daring abusers to come for us won’t do anything constructive. As much as we might want to put ourselves between GamerGate and its victims, we can’t. There are too many of them to successfully draw their fire.
We’d just end up getting stalked, harassed, doxxed, and threatened–possibly to the point of fleeing our homes.
By now, you’ve surely noticed the theme here.
It’s tempting to offer cheap platitudes to the women who’ve been the focus of these abuse campaigns, or those who might become them. To tell them to be brave, to speak their truth, to not let violent assholes scare them.
Platitudes won’t keep the cesspits of the internet from backflowing into their homes and workplaces. Platitudes won’t secure their computers and personal information; protect their families from detailed, sexually-explicit death threats; walk their kids to school; or stay at home to protect their pets while they’re at work. Platitudes won’t explain to their bosses why their companies’ websites are being DDOSed. Platitudes won’t stop bullets.
So before you lament how terrible it is to ‘let them win’ by being silent, please stop and think of a better way to phrase “I want to live in a world where the victims of abuse campaigns have a winning move.” Don’t ask women to sacrifice their names, careers, and safety to the fantasy that life is fair.
Telling women to be brave and speak up is telling them to face a violent horde unarmed. We don’t have an effective defense against these terror campaigns. We desperately need one. We’re going to follow up and see if we can develop any effective strategies.
In the meantime, I’ve already painted the target on my back, so I might as well say it.
Fuck GamerGate.